April 2015

We have a lot of people. Crimes always go proportional to population. In any society, you can assume one in 1000 will be crooks and criminals. If your whole nation is just 1 million people, you need to deal with only 1000 such crooks. If you have 1000 million people, you have a million potential criminals to deal with. Thus, you need to adjust all figures to population. Rapes are always under-reported everywhere (given that the majority of the rapes are done by close people). Even if you assume that 95% of the rapes are not reported in India, while 100% of rapes are reported in the West, India still has lower rapes as % of population. This is no excuse and thus let us move to the next 5 points.



  • We have too few police. India is among the least policed nation. We have only a little more than 1 cop for every 1000 people. Globally, this number is more than twice this. Most of our cops are taken off in protecting the politicians and bureaucrat. This leaves the number of cops less than the number of criminals. Do the math.

    1. We have too few courts and judges. The Allahabad High Court has 160 judges to manage 100 million people or close to 1 for every million people. How can a judge handle such a workload? Thus, even if the cops catch the criminal, it takes a long time to bring him to justice. 
    2. Legal system is backward. Our legal system is quite outdated. Rape and molestation laws are works in progress and are not quite near the global standards. Questions like how long the penis got inserted are asked of rape victims. This is stupid and causes many criminals to get acquitted and many victims to shy away. 
    3. Our sex ratio is poor. For every 100 guys, there are only about 92 girls. In parts of Delhi, this ratio falls to 80 girls for every 100 guys. Thus, 20+ guys for every 100 will go unmarried. 1 out of this 20 could become very depressed and vengeful. 1 out of these 10 depressed bachelors could turn more violent. Do the math and that is a lot of potential violent people.
    4. Indian women are forced in the dark for more. Due to a variety of reasons, ranging from a lack of good toilets in rural areas to outsourcing jobs that require work at night to a lack of good transportation, a lot more Indian women are forced to work out in the dark. Historically, dark, secluded areas have always attracted crime. World over, most of the murders and rapes occur this time. This would require us to dramatically upgrade the existing infrastructure - transportation and sanitation - so that less women are forced to be outside. Even better personal transportation could help the women with safer options.
    5. Our media reports more actively: This is actually a positive thing. As mentioned here and observed by people who have lived both in and out of India - Why Rape Seems Worse in India Than Everywhere Else (but Actually Isn’t  - Indian media gives a greater importance to individual rape incidents than most other media around the world. This helps put the problem right in front of our eyes and hopefully that pushes us close to reducing the rates. Most of the rest of the world, avoids reporting gruesome rape incidents. 


    These points are fundamental. While attitudes blah blah blah all are talked about, we have to first focus on things that are easy to fix. Adding more judges, toilets, police and fixing laws is not rocketscience and we need to do that before getting to "attitudes". 

    Of course, point 1 is no excuse for us to stay quiet. We need to be the best country when it comes to women safety. To see some of the solutions go here:What is the best way to deal with the degrading condition of women in India?

    Since the gang rape of a 23-year-old student on a moving bus in New Delhi last year, India has become the world’s rape capital. An American website recently satirized the problem by joking about an upcoming rape festival in the country. You can call it a reflection of the way the world thinks of India or you can call it bad taste (depending on which part of the world you are in) — but you know the image of India as rape hell has stuck when most readers of the article failed to realize that it was satire. Rape is a serious problem all over the world. So why does it seem so much worse in India?

    1. More rapes are being reported now: Along with the modernization of society, more Indian women are being educated and are going out to work. They are breaking out of the subservient mold that society had given to them and are more independent. While this means they are more likely to be sexually abused, it also means they are more likely — compared with women of a previous generation — to report rapes and confront sexual predators. In the three months after the Delhi gang rape, the number of rapes reported in the city more than doubled to 359, from the 143 reported in January-March of 2012. This doesn’t necessarily mean more rapes are happening now, just that more women are emboldened to come out and report.
    2. India actually has a high conviction rate for rape: According to the Guardian, just 7% of reported rapes in the U.K. resulted in convictions during 2011-12. In Sweden, the conviction rate is as low as 10%. France had a conviction rate of 25% in 2006. Poor India, a developing nation with countless challenges, managed an impressive24.2% conviction rate in 2012. That’s thanks to the efforts of a lot of good people — police, lawyers, victims and their families — working heroically with limited resources.
    3. The media report everything: According to Dave Prager, the American author of Delirious Delhi, crimes that “wouldn’t garner even a sentence in an American paper because so many bigger crimes would elbow it out of the way” are obsessively reported in Indian news publications. Post the Delhi gang rape, Indian media have faithfully recorded each and every rape case, highlighted them for the world and continue to do so.
    4. Most Indians, men and women, hate the reputation that rapists have given their country: No country in the world can claim to have witnessed protests against rape on the scale of India’s, where people turned out in the tens of thousands to voice their shock and sadness. It was people power that forced the government to change existing rape laws and drew the world’s attention to the problem. What happens in other countries? This may not be a typical example, but the rape of a teen girl by high school football players in the Steubenville, Ohio had many in the town sympathizing with the rapists and not the victim.

    1. Indian women have to get politically active

    The problem starts with the women. Close to half of our voters are women. But, they have never ensured that their issues are top of any party's agenda. Modiji has showed that even with 31% of the votes you could sweep the nation. If the nation's women vote en masse in a single direction, they could sweep the nation. This could help in putting gender issues at a higher level of priority. For that they need to get on the politics. Forget about handouts like 33% reservation of seats, but be more assertive in taking 50% of the seats straight out. (I could see the discrepancy even in the upvotes this answer got ;-))

    2. Gender issues a national priority

    In India, we are experts at fighting imaginary and irrelevant battles. For instance, this whole specter of Article 370 & Kashmir or getting a permanent membership at the UNSC. Those issues are clearly way low important compared with the gigantic issues ahead of us. Our government and society is spending wasted mental cycles on those. We are worried about China's military encircling us or Pakistani terrorists destroying us. 

    Every day our rapists & murderers kill more than the terrorists kill with bombs in a year and way more than what China's or Pakistan's armies have ever killed. Throughout Indian history, we always see that our enemies are seldom outside. No external power can impact India, if India is sound inside. 

    Building a strong economy and providing a strong law & order that ensures both men & women can walk safe should have way higher priority than anything else. Solutions can be made only when priorities are right. 

    3. Legal Reforms

    Our legal system is neither built on our ancient past nor the modern principles in rest of the world. Instead, it is stuck in the murky past of the 19th century Victorian morals. From anti-gay laws to handling juvenile murderers to marital rape - a bunch of Indian laws are a relic of the past & we need to substantially reform. Implementing Verma committee reforms will be a start. 

    4. A modern police force

    Our police force is woefully few and woefully under-trained.  Less than 5% of this small force are women. We need to more than double our police force to even get to a world average (about 1 policeman for every 500 people). We are ahead of only Uganda when it comes to the number of police personnel per capita. And a lot of these police are taken away for protecting politicians and bureaucrats.Of the rest, most are untrained and uneducated. We need to build a modern police force that understand the plights of women and build a lot of them. They need to patrol a lot in crime hotspots and where women go a lot. Not enough cops to combat Mumbai menace and The New York Times.

    5. More courts and fast tracking legal process

    Our legal system is swamped. This is why main criminals go Scott-free. We need to dramatically increase the number of judges and courts and cut a lot of redtape in the way of fast tracking legal proceedings. There are 32 million pending cases in India!!

    Against a sanctioned strength of 17,715 judges, more than 3,300 posts are vacant. Though the apex court has set a target of taking the combined strength of the judiciary to 30,000 in five years, the target looks difficult . This has already resulted in huge pendency of cases. Currently, there are more than 3.20 crore pending cases in different courts. Of this, nearly 2.76 crore cases are in subordinate courts while 44 lakh are pending in various HCs and nearly 60,000 in the Supreme Court.
    Govt tells Supreme Court it will appoint 50 more judges at Allahabad high court

    6. Better employment

    Close to 10% of our youth is unemployed. This is clearly unacceptable in a fast growing economy. Young, Jobless and Indian. A lot of these are loitering around bus stops, tea shops and molesting ongoers. As the old saying goes - "an idle mind is a devil's workshop". Building a national level skills program and ensuring that the unemployment falls below 5% will make sure that many of the idle minds are taken off the streets.  

    7. Better data collection

    For a nation priding on being a tech leader, our government is stuck in 17th century technology. We don't have an easy way to record, track and map crimes happening all over the nation. We need to have real time statistics about various characteristics of crime and track them on various attributes. As the old saying goes, "what you can't measure, you can't improve". 

    8. National level emergency infrastructure

    We need an equivalent of US 911 that anyone in India can call for any emergency. Our existing emergency system is woefully inadequate. Women in danger should be able to call help at the push of a button. Metadata from the calls should be transparently reported and any inaction on a emergency call should be grounds for suspension of the local police group. 

    9. Better preparation at the grassroots

    Indian women are mostly unprepared when they are walking on deserted streets. From learning self-defense techniques, to keeping simple weapons to being more situationally aware to walking in groups, people have to take a better handle of their own security. Indian neighborhoods also have build formal "citizen watch groups" to patrol the streets. Neighborhood watch

    10. Make it illegal to condone or glorify rape

    One of the senior politicians - Mulayam Singh Yadav - was caught on tape saying on the lines of  "Boy will be boys. Young men rape". Such people should be spending time behind the bars. We have no use of such politicians and they are harmful to Indian society. Modi should also make sure he fires people like Babulal Gaur in his own party (Babulal Gaur puts foot in mouth again, backs SP). Extend "hate crime laws" to these. 


    The father and uncle of a 17-year-old student in Gurgaon were arrested on Friday on charges of raping her repeatedly over a period of three years. The accused were arrested on Friday morning.
    The matter was reported to police after the girl, a Class XII student of a private school in Gurgaon, called childline (1098) on Thursday and informed them about the alleged abuse.
    The father is a government teacher in a senior secondary school and the uncle is a manager of a private bank in Gurgaon. The medical examination at Civil Hospital confirmed rape, police said.
    According to police, the girl called the helpline on Thursday as she was too scared to speak to anyone else. She was immediately taken to police where a complaint was registered against the two men.The girl’s statement was recorded by the duty magistrate under Section 164 CrPC on Friday.
    ACP (Crime) Rajesh Kumar said, “Her father, a government teacher, aged 44, allegedly raped her several times. She alleged that her uncle also raped her for three years since when she was a Class VI student.”
    Police said the abuse took place whenever she was alone at home. The first incident took place in 2009 when her uncle (aunt’s husband) raped her after finding her alone at home. Soon after, her father also started raping her. After that it became a frequent practice, police said. The men would get together at her house for drinks and then rape her. Initially, she kept mum but in 2011, she informed her mother.
    “The victim was confident that after she complained about her uncle to her mother, things would change and that he would be asked not to visit their house. But to her shock, she was scolded and was asked not to discuss the matter with anyone. The girl started getting depressed,” Kumar said.
    Police said the girl’s studies were also affected over the last few years.

    \

    जलपाइगुड़ी। पश्चिम बंगाल के जलपाइगुड़ी से इंसानियत को शर्मसार और दिल दहला देने वाली घटना सामने आई है। यहां एक नाबालिग लड़की ने अपने पिता, चाचा और अपने भाई पर बलात्कार करने का आरोप लगाया है। पीड़िता का आरोप है कि उसके साथ पिछले दो सालों से बलात्कार होता आ रहा है और इन सब के बीच वो दो बार गर्भवती भी हुई है। इस घटना से पीड़िता इतनी हताश थी कि उसने कई बार खुदकुशी करने की भी कोशिश की।

    घटना मामूली नहीं है लेकिन इस मामले में लड़की की मां की बातें सुनकर आप सन्न रह जाएंगे। पीड़िता के मुताबिक जब इस घटना के बारे में उसने अपनी मां को बताया तो उसकी मां ने उसकी मदद करने के बजाय ये कहा कि वो तुम्हारे पापा, चाचा और भाई ही तो हैं कोई गैर थोड़े ही ना हैं।

    इतना सब होने के बावजूद पीड़िता ने हार नहीं मानी और बहुत ही हिम्मत करके उसने ये बात अपनी टीचर को बता दी। इसके बाद पीड़िता के स्कूल के प्रिंसिपल और अध्यापक मिलकर पुलिस थाने गए और आरोपियों के खिलाफ केस दर्ज कराया।

    इसके बाद पुलिस ने कार्रवाई करते हुए तत्काल प्रभाव से पीड़िता के चाचा को गिरफ्तार किया और शाम होते होते उसके भाई और पिता को भी पुलिस ने गिरफ्तार कर लिया। इस बड़ी घटना में पीडिता की मां भी इन लोगों से कम गुनहगार नहीं है। पीड़िता की मां फिलहाल फरार है और पुलिस उसकी तलाश कर रही है।


    New Delhi: A 19-year-old physiotherapy student was gang-raped by her friend and three of his associates here, police said on Saturday. Three of the accused have been arrested.
    The teenager was invited by her friend Akash to his flat in east Delhi's Farsh Bazaar area on Wednesday on the pretext of celebrating a party.
    Police said Akash and his three other friends identified as Jatin, Rohit and Raman were already present. All the accused gang-raped the victim and dropped her near her house in Vivek Vihar in east Delhi early Thursday morning.
    The victim informed her family who then approached police, and a case of rape was registered against the four accused, all who are in their early twenties.
    A police officer said that Jatin, Akash and Rohit were arrested on Saturday morning from their different hideouts in the city. Police are on the lookout for Raman.

    MKRdezign

    Contact Form

    Name

    Email *

    Message *

    Powered by Blogger.
    Javascript DisablePlease Enable Javascript To See All Widget